UK tribunal says Home Office must confirm secret Apple encryption order
Apple had already turned off Advanced Data Protection for UK users and challenged the demand in court after authorities reportedly sought worldwide access, later limited to British nationals.
The UK's Investigatory Powers Tribunal ruled on Thursday that the government must confirm it sent Apple a secret order for encrypted customer information. The Home Office had argued that admitting the order would harm national security. The tribunal, an independent court where people can contest surveillance demands, rejected that claim.
Under the Investigatory Powers Act 2016, the demand is a technical capability notice. It seeks access to end-to-end encrypted data and is aimed at the cryptographic protections on iCloud accounts. Rather than comply, Apple switched off Advanced Data Protection for users in the UK and took the order to court. British authorities had reportedly asked for a way into customer data around the world, which drew criticism from US lawmakers over privacy. The government later limited the demand to data belonging to British nationals, and Apple challenged that narrower request as well. The dispute has run for a year.
Apple said it welcomes a decision that lets the public know the Home Office issued the notice. The company repeated that it has "never built a backdoor or master key" for its products or services and "never will." Privacy campaigners called the outcome a "big win for accountability, transparency and online security." A final hearing on which details of the order may be published is expected next year.